The Tool Bar: Are Garlic Presses Obsolete?

Feb032010

Sometimes, even the most experienced among us can be full-tilt blinders-on when it comes to the necessity — or not — of certain tools, whether or not you’ve been to culinary school.

Take the lowly garlic clove. Cooks and chefs through the centuries have wrestled with extracting the meat from that frustratingly-clingy skin, including me. I’ve tried rolling cloves in those smelly rubber tubes, hand-peeling, and even just chopping the damn thing before picking the papery sheath away from the good stuff.

After struggling one time too many, I posted a plea to my Facebook friends with garlic bits still wedged under my fingernails — How do I get the damn skin off? The universal answer was to smash it with the side of a knife, and then remove.

Well, duh. Why didn’t I think of that?

In any case, even the most newfangled tool can pale next to a tried-and-true old-fashioned method. And some chefs are notoriously inflexible about using anything that places them in a less-than-valiant light. Witness Top Chef’s Gail Simmons recent rant against electric tools.

A recent story about garlic presses in the UK Guardian essentially assassinates the character of the lowly tool, equating it as the spawn of the devil.

I tend to agree. I’ve always been frustrated with the amount of garlic left in the press, and digging it out and then chopping it up seems to cancel out the whole need for the press in the first place.

So what about you? Do you swear by your garlic press or swear at it? Leave a comment below.

Tags:
Filed Under:

11 comments so far…Leave yours

Kez Feb 03 2010

It’s only one of several garlic tools I use, but I do use one. It “purees” garlic to a good consistency for blending into sauces. A microplane works similarly but I find it’s a little more time consuming.

I don’t have issues with the fraction of a clove that’s wasted.

Skin that’s hard to remove is a sign that the garlic is underripe – or so I’ve been told.

David P. Hagan Feb 03 2010

You could just mince the garlic then use a bench scraper to crush it into a fine paste. Just put the blade onto the minced garlic, press and drag. You can do it with a knife, but why would you want to drag your knife blade across your cutting board.

David P. Hagan Feb 03 2010

Also, was it Goodfellas where the guys in prison were slicing garlic paper thin with a razor blade, or am I completely thinking of the wrong movie?

I’ve given up on my garlic press and now use a microplane. Since I’m usually grating ginger for the same dish it’s no more work to clean up.

I like David’s idea of using a bench scraper.

Elena Feb 04 2010

Being a food network junkie, I have watched several of the chefs and my own Mother when she was alive take a french knife on the flat side and give each clove a good whack. The skin/paper comes off easily and then chop to your desired consistency. Again with the back and flat side of you knife scrape up the garlic from the cutting board. Works fast and great every time. The only problem a person could have is not whacking the garlic hard enough, but a second whack does no harm.
So my favorite garlic tool…. a good french knife.

Nora Brown Feb 04 2010

Whack-n-mince is the way to go. You do need to be careful though.

David P. Hagan Feb 04 2010

Since Charmian brought up ginger, has anyone ever used one of those ginger grating plates? If so, did it work well?

And as for the bench scraper idea, I have one called the Bash and Chop, where the metal is rolled up into a handle that allows it to lay perfectly flat on your board. It lets you really pulverize that garlic into a paste. I love mine, and they’re only about 5 bucks.

And speaking of great kitchen gadgets, I bought a pastry blender over the weekend that will actually stand up to being used. Its a heavier gage steel than the ones you normally see, and has only 4 blades instead of 5. It’s made by Norpro. They had Norpro’s with 5 blades right next to it, and the 5 blades bent with barely any pressure. the 4 blades I couldn’t bend at all. Definitely the way to go. Do I feel bad for bending the other one in the store? A little, but I want to make sure that the equipment I buy is quality.

Lisa Feb 04 2010

Ah, David, you’ve inspired me to write a whole new post, which will be going up shortly.

Question: Re: The Bash & Chop: Is that your own name for it? Or is that an actual name?

David P. Hagan Feb 04 2010

The Bash and Chop (actual name) is made by Progressive. It’s actually quite amazing. It even has a little ruler on it. Great for dividing dough, scooping up chopped veggies, or as previously stated turning cloves of garlic into a flavorful mush.

Also, in your new post, you spelled my last name wrong. Don’t worry, everybody does. I’m glad I’m so inspiring.

Andrea Feb 05 2010

Best little product ever; the Garlic Zoom. Open the top, put in the garlic, run it up and down on its little wheels a few times (the more you do it, the more finely sliced the garlic). Open it up, tip out the garlic, rinse to clean. No garlic smell on your hands. http://www.firebox.com/product/2280/Garlic-Zoom?via=ser

When they taught us to use garlic in my high school cooking class (oh how time flies), they simply said to crush it with our chef knives, and that garlic presses were useless. It’s basically a ricer, if I remember correctly—isn’t it?

Add your comment
required
required but hidden
optional

You may use Textile formatting including:

  • _italics_ = italics
  • *bold* = bold
  • "text":url = text

© Lisa Rogak 2010 • Site by Nora Brown Design