Chef Profile: Holly Smith

Oct132009

Contest Winner

Before we get started, I’d like to announce the winner of Frank Stitt’s Bottega Favorita cookbook: Deborah R., who wrote, “I love the way a good Southern chef can make a heavenly Italian favorite just that much better. I signed up for your newsletter — not that I needed the bribe, but I also appreciate the chance to win Chef Stitt’s book.”

What are you waiting for? Enter this week’s giveaway — one of several — below, but of course, not before reading the latest installment of our profiles of the contestants on the current season of The Next Iron Chef :

Oops! For the second week in a row, the chef we had lined up to feature that week was the same chef who got voted off the island. Sorry, Holly! While I don’t think that being featured in BehindTheKnife.com is a jinx, you know the third time’s a charm. Hopefully, the ax won’t fall on the chef on deck, Chef…sorry! I think I’ll keep that information to myself for the time being.

For me, the greatest moment of the Week Two episode was the absolute look of glee on Chef Mehta’s face when it was disclosed that Chef Trevino — assigned to prepare a deconstructed version of dolmas, the classic Greek dish of stuffed grape leaves — discovered that Mehta had run off with the kitchen’s entire stash of grape leaves. A classic TV moment.

Okay, here we go:

The Chef: Holly Smith of Cafe Juanita in Kirkland, Washington, where the focus is on Northern Italian cuisine. Holly won the 2008 James Beard Foundation award for Best Chef in the Northwest.

The Toolbox: Forget about the judges’ criticism for a moment. After the stunt that Chef Mehta pulled with the grape leaves, methinks that perhaps Chef Smith just wasn’t mean and conniving enough to progress further in the competition. Example A: She SHARES her tools! “Right now, all of my knives are strewn all over the Café Juanita kitchen, and everyone has their preferences to which knives they like,” she admits. “However, when I travel, I use a bright orange canvas rollout knife kit — you’ll see it on The Next Iron Chef.” Um, maybe if you catch a rerun.

The Sentimental Tool: “I have a handmade knife made by Bob Kramer (KramerKnives.com), which was given to me by my friends at Dahlia Lounge," she says. Note: Bob Kramer is a master knifesmith whose products are loved by chefs worldwide, while Dahlia Lounge is run by the famous Seattle chef Tom Douglas.

The Long-Lost Tool: “I used to carry a meat cleaver in there, but now I just leave it at Café Juanita,” she says, admitting that it’s just too heavy to carry around. Perhaps if she waved it around on the set of The Next Iron Chef, she’d be around to cook another day.

Paging Alton Brown/A Strange Thing In Her Toolbox: “I think I just found a side towel from when we shot The Next Iron Chef that made its way into my knife roll by accident.” A likely story…what could it fetch on eBay?

The Professional Analysis: “A psychologist looking at my toolbox would probably say that I’m able to make great things happen with little fuss,” she says. “While there aren’t very many fancy tools in it, I use the basics to create incredible things.”

Thou Shalt Not Covet Another Chef’s Tools: Says Chef Smith: “I was definitely intrigued by Chef Mehta’s tool kit. With those pastry chefs, you never know what you are going to find in there.”

BehindTheKnife.com Bonus

One lucky reader will win a copy of the new book The Berghoff Cafe , by Carlyn Berghoff with Nancy Ross Ryan.

It’s easy to enter. Just leave a comment below with your opinion on whether or not Chef Smith was unfairly booted, and then sign up for our new weekly newsletter The Blowtorch. The Blowtorch will contain giveaways that won’t be mentioned on the BehindTheKnife.com website.

Read our standard rules. Contest ends October 20th at 11:59 p.m.

28 comments so far…What's your opinion?

Andrew Gordon Oct 13 2009

who am i do judge the wisdom of the judges?

christopher h Oct 14 2009

i’m sad to see her go, but i didn’t think it was unfair

Carol Oct 14 2009

I signed up for the newsletter, and I do not agree with the judges about letting Chef Smith go, it was unwarranted.

janeh Oct 14 2009

I would have liked to see her stay longer.

Angela J Oct 14 2009

i have no opinion, don’t watch, but would like the book!

angie Oct 15 2009

I don’t think she should’ve gone yet.

Carol Lawrence Oct 15 2009

Don’t watch so I can’t say. Maybe I’ll tune in since you piqued my curiosity. newsletter subscriber.

Jason Nickolay Oct 15 2009

I don’t think it was entirely unfair. She deserved it a little. I would of liked to see her on there a little longer

jason(at)allworldautomotive(dot)com

Bonnie L Shepard Oct 16 2009

When life gives us lemons…

Tonya Froemel Oct 16 2009

Well, all but one will eventually go.

Deborah R Oct 16 2009

While I thought Chef Smith did well, the judges have a better sense of the larger picture than I possibly could…so no, I don’t think she was unfairly booted.

Daniel Morrell Oct 17 2009

don’t know, but need all the help i can get cooking

Kim H. Oct 18 2009

I think it’s a tough competition. Even a good or great chef can be booted by having a bad day.

I would say that by the scope of the competition it was right she was booted off. But that by no means she isn’t a good chef. She either had a bad day or wasn’t up to that particular competition.

I love watching these kinds of shows, and I know even the ones that get kicked off are VERY GOOD chefs.

Lia checkers Oct 19 2009

She should of stayed longer but thats how it goes

Bekah Oct 19 2009

It all works out for a reason…so, yes.

shawna Oct 19 2009

She should have stayed longer.

Ed Nemmers Oct 19 2009

It was not correct, but neither was Gene Hackman winning over Jaye Davidson.

Aisling Oct 19 2009

Competitions between professionals are tough, but I’m sorry to see her go so soon. (And looking forward to receiving your newsletter!)

Susan A Oct 19 2009

I thought Chef Smith did well, but we don’t know what the exact judging criteria is all about. Yes, they tell us, but do they really? Also the tasting is a personal choice as far as what types of flavors the judge is looking for.

The judges probably have more information on what goes on behind the scenes that may influence the votes.

Plus what plans does the network have for the winner?

Darcy B Oct 20 2009

I think she is a very talented chef—but they all are— I was surprised that she went home—but I didn’t get to taste her food(I would have loved to) so I can’t say she was treated unfairly (well she was in the beginning of the episode when they were grabbing for the ethnic cooking vessels.
kakihararocks@gmail.com

Rosey Oct 20 2009

There are others I would have preferred to get the boot.

pam shockley Oct 20 2009

I’m signed up for the Blowtorch. I was sad to see her go, but then they don’t let me decide!!

Thanks.

Larry Harms Oct 20 2009

I thought it was fair..judges call.

gloria Oct 20 2009

I really don’t know but want to enter! I am a subscriber.

Bridget Combs Oct 20 2009

subscriber. Fair but unfortunate

Sand Oct 20 2009

I think it was fair.

Veronica Garrett Oct 20 2009

Judging is subjective. Can’t say her getting boot was unfair.

Kimberly Murat Oct 20 2009

Someone has to go, that’s the name of the game. It by no means should mean she is untalented. Like others have said I would have prefered to see a different person go this week.

Comments are closed for this article.

© Lisa Rogak 2010 • Site by Nora Brown Design